Voicing the Pain

This Mother’s Day I had the  privilege of closing out our Sunday services with a song from my album. Mother’s Day is an amazing opportunity to celebrate our moms, but can also be a very hard, emotional time. I wanted to take a few moments to honor mothers who have lost, have had trouble conceiving, and those who had recently lost their mom’s. Mother’s Day 2009 was a tough one for my wife Danielle as she carried our firstborn who we knew would die any day from Hydrops. We ended up having a stillbirth 26  months into the pregnancy.

I chose to close the service with “Right By My Side.” It was a song I wrote in deep despair, when I felt alone and abandoned.  I had used up all my plans and safety nets, and found I was not enough.  Though in my darkness, I was reminded that I was not alone. God was with me in my pain. Right by my side.


This pain is more than I can bear
Its tearing me apart

I’m close to caving in
I try to push away the fear
to keep appearances
But I can’t hold it back
To fight away the tears

I pray this night will fade to grey
But I can’t see the dawn
And my strength is running out

But You’re here with me
You’re here with me
Right by my side

This sorrow’s more than I can take
My heart’s been ripped apart
I’m close to blowing up

I’ve used up my ability
My plans and safety nets
and found I’m not enough

Sometimes I can’t tell what I feel
where I really stand
what I truly believe

These times have brought me to my knees
though they are cut and sore
it’s where I need to be

I had hoped my song would connect with those hurting in our community, but I had no idea how powerful the moment would be. I felt a connection as I played the song, though it wasn’t until after each service, when I was able to talk with and listen to people’s stories, that my whole heart engaged. One woman shared with me that this was her first Mother’s Day without her mom. Through her tears she expressed how this was the first moment since here mother’s death she felt her loneliness lift. It was also the first moment she had opened up to someone in our church about her struggle and loss. I spoke with several mother’s who had lost children, who were ready to finally release the bitterness they held towards God. Others shared for the first time heart wrenching stories of divorce, job loss, drug use, and abuse. They were so thankful I took the moment to recognize those that were hurting and share the hope that though God may not take away our pain, he is with us every step. One older man thanked me for giving his pain a voice. He had struggled for so long to let it out, to find the words. He felt as if I had shared his story from the stage. It was one of the most powerful and humbling moments I have experienced in ministry.

So why was this moment so special? Why were people so grateful for that moment of honesty and transparency? Was is because I was going above and beyond or because its something we normally don’t do very well?

All this pain, sitting in our auditorium, hiding behind plastic smiles and designer clothes. All the despair stuffed away and covered up every Sunday with the usual greetings and rhetoric. The stuff we never see, or the stuff we choose to ignore. We easily voice the joy and share the good stuff in our lives, but why do we hide the rest? If our churches are the body of Christ, why are we as members and leaders slow to open up? What are we scared of? We need to ditch the masks, performances, and cliches and get down an dirty. One of the first elements of authentic community is transparency.

I’m not saying that every community and church ignores pain at all…It just seems that some of us are afraid to get into it in our corporate settings…maybe it takes too much time. maybe it doesn’t fit within our service times. Maybe we’re afraid that if we open up the all the stuff crammed inside, we may not be able to cap it.  Maybe we’re afraid of judgment and ridicule. There are many great small/support  groups and recovery programs, but I think we need to take more time to address the hurt in our big rooms, and allow God to meet us where we are at instead of faking it.

So how do we do voice the pain? How do we as a community better embrace the hurting? How do we as people let our walls down? How do we open up? I want to know your thoughts. Those of you doing it, what is working? Those of us that aren’t, what is holding us back?

  • http://www.twitter.com/cgonzo Chris Gonzalez

    Great post. Really appreciating your CD.

    Two thoughts that hit me:

    1. If the smaller communities of the church aren't dealing with pain in smaller settings to wrestle through their hurt, then it either won't happen in the big room or it will but it will seem fake and staged.

    2. The gospel. Big group, small group, whatever group. If the church isn't saturating people in a deep robust gospel that frees people up to not be okay, because their being okay isn't dependent on them but on the cross of Christ, then people aren't going to be really freed up to honestly acknowledge their pain.

  • http://scottwaterman.wordpress.com/ Scott Waterman

    I think it has something to do with how our leaders communicate their own pain. Many pastors hold back from the alter. Some of the most authentic and powerful worship I've witnessed was when our pastor unexpectedly lost a good friend hours before church and still decided to preach. The pain was visible, we hurt with him and held him up; experientially, we were collectively hurting. Outward joy induces joy in others, the same principle also applies to pain and sorrow. We resonate with our leaders who show us their pain. Often we see our leaders as 'strong' and 'capable', but within Christianity we need to drop the pretense and start be show our momentary authenticity. It's why I always ask, “Why doesn't anyone talk about how hard it is to start to and continue to follow Christ?” I honestly think it's because most preachers would rather talk about the lighter side of the coin rather than the deal with the entire coin. We must deal with the dark night of the soul that will happen. I think that when we openly deal with the inevitability of pain, we induce a lot of healing.

  • http://www.c-rev.com/blog Brent Chavez

    Great points, Scott! I agree 100%. Some of the moments that have really struck me in corporate church gatherings are those small moments when you know someone is walking through trials, and they are forced to show themselves stripped down and broken in the midst of it. It reminds the rest of us of our own humanity and our own hurt that we might not be so apt to show otherwise. Thanks for this post Ryan, it's been such a blessing to be a part of such a large church, that has a tighter community and one that loves each other more than some of the small churches I have been at!

  • http://lauriann-faint-hearted.blogspot.com Lauri Barkman

    Ryan, I was very grateful that you shared your song on Mother's day. My mother is still with me, so I am blessed to share this day with her, however I am not a mother. I am not married and have no children, and I will be 35 in July. I know this doesn't compare to others who have suffered more, however I feel alone. I have spent most of my life raising my siblings and my nieces and nephews as well. I love children and feel a part of me is missing. This song that says You're here with me, right by my side reminds me that God is my husband, father and provider and one day my hearts desire will be met. I have alot of pain, have had many friendships and relationships change or leave, its hard to share with others in a big church because there are so many people. I like to vent by blogging and sometimes I find someone who will listen. I have epilepsy and my seizures have increased, so I am unable to drive, because of this I am unable to come to church as often as I like…its also amazing who stays your friends when the dark times come..I have lost some friends I never thought I would. You Ryan have a very sensitive and caring heart and am proud to have you at our church.. May God bless you and Danielle and this new baby on the way. Thank you

  • Amanda Chavez

    First I want to say thanks for such a thought provoking post. I have been really chewing on this for the last week or so since you posted it. I absolutely agree that it is important to address peoples pain when we can in a corporate setting. It may be the only opportunity we get to reach out to some of the people who are hurting or who are searching for Christ. Being transparent is something God is definitely working on in me. I have been so guilty of getting caught up in the business and keeping schedule that I forget the whole reason why we have church in the first place…to show people the love of Christ. It absolutely breaks my heart to think of the people that could be coming in and coming out with never feeling that love. Who are hurting but don't get the opportunity to talk or pray with someone. I know it can be intimidating to be the person who comes forward when everyone else is leaving. A thought I had…maybe if instead of having people come forward there could be people towards the back of the church that people could go to if they need prayer and then walk with them over to a seperate classroom to chat with them? It could make it more of an intimate setting and not have to hurry anyone along because the next service is starting. Like I said just a thought. :) For me I am trying to model transparency with those I interact with on Sundays and during the week. I think it can be easier to open up when others are opening up and being honest. And then if they continue that on and are transparent and open with those they are around, the culture can slowly change. I really appreciate you and Danielle being so open with what you guys went through with losing Michaela. I have grown so much in my faith by seeing how God strengthened yours through such a difficult trial. I know you guys have inspired and encouraged so many. Brent and I are absolutely blessed to know you guys!!!

  • Chris Nikirk

    Ryan, great thoughts. I appreciated that Mother's Day closer so much. In 2001 I found myself in exactly the same situation you were in: worship leader at growing church, pressing on after the death of our first born daughter, just 11 days after her birth. I felt the pressure to keep up appearances and be an example of strength. But I had no idea what to do with the pain.

    I dont know what the answer is, but I do know that hiding pain and struggles from the church didn't work. Ignoring the pain and grief has cost me dearly.

    Keep asking these questions and hopefully we'll come up with some answers. I wrote a song about my experience a few years back and to me the most honest line I've ever written so far is in that song:

    “And the pain's as strong as the whiskey in my hand.”